icon Add as a preferred source Download PDF version
Mr Charles Thornton was fined £7,000 and ordered to pay £2,933.33 in costs with a surcharge of £170
The fire alarm and detection system had not been tested, serviced, and maintained as it should have

On the 4th September 2016, North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service were called to a report of a fire at flats on Fulford Road in York. During the incident, which had been caused by an electrical fault near to the fuse board, fire officers found that the fire alarm and detection system provided for the two flats and communal hallway was not working. Further investigation found that the landlord, Mr. Charles Thornton, had not carried out a fire risk assessment. During an interview Mr. Thornton admitted that he had not planned or organised his fire safety responsibilities adequately. The fire alarm and detection system had not been tested, serviced, and maintained as it should have.

Total fine of £10,103.33

At York Magistrates Court on Wednesday 7th June 2017, Mr Charles Thornton pleaded guilty to three contraventions of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. Mr Charles Thornton was fined £7,000 and ordered to pay £2,933.33 in costs with a surcharge of £170. A total cost of £10,103.33.

Station Manager, David Watson of North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service said; “North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service officers work closely with City of York Council when dealing with fire safety issues involving flats, houses in multiple occupation and shared houses.”

“In this case, following the fire incident, it was found that the landlord was responsible for a number of flats across the city. Having good organisation, planning, control and monitoring of fire safety arrangements is essential for any responsible person. Within those fire safety arrangements fire risk assessments and adequate maintenance of fire alarm and detection systems are essential.”

North Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service will in most cases give responsible persons chance to comply with the legislation before taking legal proceedings. However, where cases are found where there is risk to life of death or serious injury in the event of fire, prosecution will be considered and where appropriate taken.”

Keeping tenants and properties safe

Tom Brittain, assistant director of housing and community safety, said: “We work hard with landlords and letting agents to ensure that they comply with legislation that exists to protect and keep their tenants safe – as well as their properties.”

“Besides supporting the investigation and prosecution, we remind landlords to contact us for details of their legal responsibilities.”

Ms. Karen Galloway prosecuting stated that; “The Fire and Rescue Service’s decision to prosecute was not taken lightly and this measure is only taken in the most serious cases. The responsible person is always in a position of authority, their lack of actions should have been foreseeable to prevent, in the event of fire, persons being put at risk of death or serious injury. The contraventions in this case were serious and would have continued had the Fire Authority not acted immediately.”

North Yorkshie Fire and Rescue Service would like to remind business owners and landlords that it is important that they are aware of the legislative requirements they need to comply with including having an up to date fire risk assessment.

In case you missed it

WAGNER's Fire Protection Solutions At BUILDINX 2025
WAGNER's Fire Protection Solutions At BUILDINX 2025

WAGNER Group GmbH will be presenting pioneering solutions for fire protection in modern logistics properties at BUILDINX 2025 in Dortmund from November 18 to 20, 2025. The foc...

Spare A Minute For Maintenance
Spare A Minute For Maintenance

With new fire safety regulations around the corner and a renewed focus on responsible persons and coordination, Karen Trigg of Allegion UK discusses the significance of fire door h...

Fire-Dex Unveils Fire Investigation PPE For Safety
Fire-Dex Unveils Fire Investigation PPE For Safety

Fire investigators have long worked in a gray area of protection where full structural turnouts are overkill, but single-layer garments may not cover every single hazard they encou...

vfd